Status:
Ready to upload
Record number:
2060
Adverse Occurrence type:
MPHO Type:
Estimated frequency:
The estimated frequency of Adenovirus infections following renal transplantation varies from 6.5% (Kozlowski T, et al 2010 - see reference below) and 11.5% (Hierholzer et al 1992), although the specific incidence of donor derived Adenovirus infection has not been reported.
Time to detection:
The time to detection of symptomatic acute human infection adenovirus species 34 (HAdV-34) postrenal transplant in one recipient was one month. The second kidney transplant recipient from the same donor was asymptomatic with negative HAdV-34 neutralizing antibody pretransplant but tested positive for HAdV-34 neutralizing antibody at 8 weeks posttransplant.
Alerting signals, symptoms, evidence of occurrence:
The symptomatic patient developed low-grade fever, lymphopenia, hematuria, pyuria and elevated creatinine (1.69 mg/dl compared to 1.15 mg/dl one month prior to onset of symptoms) with tenderness over the allograft with pyelonephritis at 4 weeks posttransplant. CT scan showed progressive perinephric stranding and allograft edema. Serum HAdV nucleic acid testing at approximately 5 weeks posttransplant was positive at 6 x 10(6) copies/ml. Core biopsy of the allograft showed tubular necrosis and "smudge" chromatin with histologic findings consistent with adenovirus. He responded to cidofovir and probenecid with improvement in renal function. The second kidney recipient was asymptomatic. The donor heart and lungs were transplanted to separate patients who were asymptomatic and were not tested for the presence of HAdV neutralizing antibodies or PCR. In references listed below, 3 patients were described by Koslowski T, et al with donor derived HAdV infection, one donor with 2 recipients, with hemorrhagic cystitis and nephritis at 11 days requiring transplant nephrectomy in one patient and the second with dysuria and positive urine for AdV at 19 days and recovery of renal function when immunosuppression was decreased. The third patient from a separate donor developed delayed graft function requiring hemodialysis and negative biopsy for viral injury and gradual improvement in renal function. Creatinine increased to 5.3 mg/dl requiring repeat kidney biopsy consistent with HAdV, acute tubular necrosis with microabscesses and required transplant nephrectomy. Report of two patients by Dawood et al showed both patients with disseminated adenovirus, one at 4 weeks posttransplant, the second at 27 months posttransplant, both recovering with Cidofovir and IVIG. A report by Rady et al described a case of adenovirus nephritis presenting 6 weeks posttransplant, recovering with lowering of immunosuppression and IVIG. A review of 17 kidney transplant recipients in Thailand with adenovirus infection between 2007 - 2010 reported 76.5% of cases developing within 3 months of transplantation with symptoms ranging from fever and dysuria to allograft dysfunction.
Demonstration of imputability or root cause:
The donor was found to have positive HAdV-34 neutralizing antibodies which is not commonly found in the environment with both kidney recipients showing negative pretransplant HAdV-34 neutralizing antibodies and seroconversion posttransplant, consistent with probable or proven donor transmission. While the heart and lung recipients remained asymptomatic and were not tested for HAdV, the HAdV-34 neutralizing antibodies pretransplant were not performed, and it is unknown if they had protective antibodies.
Imputability grade:
2 Probable
Groups audience:
Keywords:
References:
Suggest new keywords:
donor transmission
adenovirus
kidney transplantation
Suggest references:
Pettengill MA, et al. Probable Donor-Derived Human Adenovirus Type 34 Infection in 2 Kidney Transplant Recipients From the Same Donor. Open Forum Infect Dis. 2018 Dec 26;6(3):ofy354. doi: 10.1093/ofid/ofy354. eCollection 2019 Mar.
Kozlowski T, Vickeleit V, Andreoni K. Donor-transmitted adenovirus infection causing kidney allograft nephritis and graft loss. Transplant Infectious Disease 2011:13: 168-173
Watcharanan SP, Avery R, et al. Adenovirus Disease after Kidney Transplantation: Course of Infection and Oucome in Relation to Blood Viral Load and Immune Recovery. American Journal of Transplantation 2011; 11:1308-1314
Rady K, Walters G, et al. Allograft Adenovirus Nephritis. Clin Kidney J 2014; 289-292
Dawood U, Nelson A, et al. Disseminated Adenovirus infection in Kidney Transplant Recipients. Nephrology 19, Supplement 1. 2014; 10-13
Hierholzer JC, Atuk A, Swaltney JM. New Human Adenovirus isolated from a renal transplant recipient: description and characterization of candidate adenovirus type 34. Journal of Clinical Microbiology 1975; 1(4): 366-376
Note:
MG note: I'm not sure who completed the first review, but it appears this was not saved as "first review complete" but is ready for second review. Note from first reviewer that was in the expert comments section, so I moved it here: "I would recommend removing the Kozlowski paper (#1383) from the journal list and using it as a reference for the Pettengill paper, as it also did not include donor data." I think that means we need to merge 1383 into this record please.
6/22/2024 MG: Oscar did the second review via email to me. For better clarity, please reject record 1383 while ensuring the suggested references are added to this record (Done_EP). There is something mentioned in the alerting signs section about how one of the recipients responded, but not much by way of clinical "advice" on management - although I get the impression there isn't much to say. Aurora can take a look before this is uploaded, and otherwise this is all ready to go.
Expert comments for publication:
This is the first report of probable donor transmission of adenovirus infection proven by documented seroconversion of recipients to the same strain as the donor, with serologic testing of the donor and both recipients pre and post transplantation. The incidence of transmission from a seropositive donor to seronegative recipients is known to occur, but previous reports of donor transmission, including Kozlowski et al do not report on donor status. It is likely that recipients who develop acute adenovirus infection within 1-2 months of transplantation are primarily donor related but future cases would benefit from donor testing to better establish transmission.